Proudly serving all of Florida with offices in Tampa, Orlando, and Fort Myers

Must I Prove I Have Sinkhole Loss?

Feb 11, 2015 | Residential Blog Posts

If you live in Florida and have sinkhole coverage, must you prove to your insurance company that the sinkhole was the cause of damage to your home? In the past, the legal answer was, “Yes.” The burden of proof lay squarely on your back. Recently, however a Florida judge overturned the ruling. Policyholders are no longer required to prove that damage to their homes was caused by a sinkhole.

Take the case of Alfred Mejia, from Polk County, who after submitting a sinkhole claim to his insurance company, was denied because the engineering company stated that the damage to Mr. Mejia’s Lakeland home was not sinkhole-related. Both parties went to court. Mr. Mejia was required to present evidence that the structural damage to his Polk County home was indeed due to a sinkhole even though he had asked for jury instructions to consider only that the home was damaged while it was covered by his sinkhole policy. This would have forced his insurance company to prove that the damage was not covered under the policy.

Alfred Mejia lost his case in court and then appealed. Late November 2014, the court agreed to the appeal and a new trial was scheduled. Judge Stevan T. Northcutt ruled that policyholders who are under an all-risk contract were only required to prove that their home or property was damaged while they were covered by the policy. Now, it is the insurance company who must prove that the damage or loss was not covered.

The Florida Second District Court of Appeals stated that during the trial, the court had excluded by mistake, for over three years, the Florida insurance company had paid almost $9.5 million in fees to BCI, the company that concluded Alfred Mejia’s home was not damaged by sinkhole activity. The fees were used for “expert witnesses” from BCI.

Do you suspect you may have sinkhole damage? Speak to the professionals at Helicon, 844-HELICON (844-435-4266). 

i 3 Table of Contents

Foundation sinking in Florida clay: What homeowners need to know

Have you ever wondered why homes in Florida often face foundation problems? Living in Florida means dealing with clay soil that constantly expands and contracts, and that movement puts serious pressure on your home’s foundation. You might notice cracks in your walls...

Repair Eroded Seawall Structures with Easy DIY Tips and Expert Advice

Erosion doesn’t wait. If your seawall has started to wear down, it’s already putting your property at risk, letting water slowly steal the soil that’s supposed to protect your foundation. The good news? You can fix it before the damage gets worse. So how do you repair...

Permanent Structural Repair Options for Lasting Home Safety

Structural damage isn’t just a cosmetic problem; it threatens your home’s safety, value, and peace of mind. Cracks in walls, uneven floors, or shifting foundations can worsen quickly if left untreated. The real challenge? Many quick fixes only hide the symptoms...

How to Level Uneven Floors Quickly and Easily at Home

Uneven floors can throw off more than just your furniture; they mess with your home’s balance, safety, and even your peace of mind. So, if your floors feel a little “off,” chances are they actually are. But don’t panic, you’re not alone, and this isn’t a hopeless DIY...

Contact us anytime!